Tuesday, December 2, 2008

Introducing Homer and Retribution

I will be discussing part of my dissertation on Monday at the Kenan colloquium in ethics. For this event I have written a new introduction to my dissertation that deals in a general way with many of the topics of interest to me. Here it is:

Ce châtiment d'une rigueur géométrique, qui punit automatiquement l'abus de la force, fut l'objet premier de la méditation chez les Grecs. Il constitue l'âme de l'épopée.
-Simone Weil, "L’Iliad ou le Poème de la Force," Paris, 1940

Simone Weil’s realization that retribution, châtiment, lies at the heart of the Iliad remains true, perhaps even more true, of the Odyssey. At its center is a thematic organization articulated by the Greek concept tisis and dealing with the foundational issues of retribution, suffering, justice, and their mutual relations.

Tisis, which I provisionally define as the act of exacting or suffering retributive justice, frames the narrative. In his opening, programmatic speech (1.32-43), Zeus justifies the ways of gods against the complaints of men, using the concept of tisis, thus presenting to the poem’s audience at the outset a working interpretive paradigm that is to be developed as the poem proceeds. The closing scene of the poem presents another situation where the concept of tisis organizes and motivates the action: the kin of the suitors, whom Odysseus, acting out of a claim to tisis, has just slain, themselves make claims to tisis against Odysseus and his household (24.426-37). Accordingly, they mobilize a force, seeking after retributive killings of their own. In the event, hostilities between the parties are not so much resolved as obliterated. Athena, appearing as a dea ex machina, imposes a final, peaceful settlement by fiat. Zeus causes the killings of the suitors that Odysseus performed out of tisis to be forgotten, as he proclaims in another programmatic speech that one feels must lie in responsion to his first (24.478-86).

The final scenes of the poem have often been considered—going back, perhaps, as far as the Alexandrian scholars Aristophanes and Aristarchus—deficient and inorganic with respect to rest of the poem. But the “Continuation,” as this section is sometimes called, reinforces an oft overlooked unity of structure and theme: hanging over the whole epic is the problem of tisis, which in the end only an act of divine intervention can, if not solve, at least, seemingly remove—though the contingent effects of the grand act of collective amnesia are left unexplored. What will be done with the beds, the vineyards, the homes—in short, all the spaces that the suitors occupied in the lives of the survivors—now inexplicably empty? But the poem claims for itself a happy ending in which philotes, wealth, and peace abound (24.476,486). This glücklicher Ausgang, as Uvo Hölscher calls it, is only the contingent dénouement of a more primary story of tisis, which, properly, has no end, only new beginnings. Thus when Athena complains to Zeus that a new civil war is about to break out between the suitors’ kin and Odysseus’ household, he responds, “Didn’t you yourself devise the plan that Odysseus should return and take vengeance (tisis) upon those men?” The implication is that one plot of tisis necessarily begets another.

With this new threat, the poem itself seems in danger of coming undone at its end and trailing off indefinitely, as a new epic of war, a new Iliad, impends. At its close, the poem settles on an arbitrary ending—perhaps the only kind of ending possible—in which the claims of the suitors’ kin are simply deleted, though ironically they achieved remembrance far beyond the limitations of mortal memory in the form of immortal epic. For the poem’s audience, who, thanks to the distance that the mediation of the text imposes, escape the spell of forgetting, the impression of the centrality of tisis to the plot remains indelible. Any feeling of arbitrariness in the construction of the ending of the poem only enhances the sense that the claims of tisis, being inherently arbitrary themselves, form the central structure of the plot. Tisis characterizes the conflicts that shape the plot and meaning of the entire epic’s story.

37 comments:

魅力 said...

當身處逆境時,要能忍一時之氣,吃一時之苦,並及早確立自己的目標,總有一天,你會嘗到那甘美的果實。........................................

婉亞 said...

Drive carefully. It is not only cars that can be recalled by their Maker.............................................

v奎峰奎峰 said...

hello~~........................................

育霖 said...

Hello~Nice to meet you~..................................................

逸凡逸凡 said...

Nice Post~!!!. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

嘉偉 said...

thanks................................................

彥宏志宏 said...

謝謝分享好文章........................................

ValarieEdmon靜宜 said...

Necessity is the mother of invention.......................................................

Nath0113anaelDrumm said...

Many a true word is spoken in jest.......................................................

文婷 said...

成人線上卡通 視訊網 正妹聊天 免費成人圖 交友援 av女優寫真貼圖 漫畫性感美女 微風線上影片 自拍.偷拍 ut聊聊天室 成人視訊 情趣用品 18禁卡通遊戲 巨乳美少女 咆曉小咾鼠影城 免費a片 線上觀看情色影片 免費線上觀看色情 一夜情人 383成人影音成 sexygirl 裸照 虐待美女 辣妹寫真集dvd 淫亂人妻日記 歐美熟女色情圖片 免費視訊 空姐圖貼 69成人a圖下載 微風寫真館 85cc影 微風論壇情色 嘟嘟 xo777 情色性愛貼圖 台北援交網 嘟嘟情色網 鋼管秀 下載av 洪爺娛樂往 台灣大奶影片 sexy888影片分享區 下載 巨乳人妻初體驗h漫 台灣性愛文學網 後宮18jack 限制級國片 0204成人 免費性愛觀看 走光

怡君 said...

a片a圖一夜情一葉情人妻激情情色寫真美女自拍辣妹自拍正妹自拍美女走光辣妹走光正妹走光脫衣秀脫衣走光色情自慰自拍成人全裸打炮打手槍打飛機巨乳巨奶女優大奶性交性愛淫蕩淫慾淫亂淫婦淫妹

GlenS筱財 said...

傻氣的人喜歡給心 雖然每次都被笑了卻得到了別人的心..................................................

kittycha said...

做愛 淫慾 s18x愛 寫真 77p2p 辣妹 淫婦 av 美女 美女聊天室 後宮聊天 打手槍 視訊 18禁視訊 貼圖 xPlus.av 援交打炮 女優 live173 173 85免費 uthome聊天室 一夜情 xvideo 免費視訊 情色聊天 交友聊天 影音視訊聊天室 情人視訊 a片

彥安 said...

要持續更新下去喲!!祝你心情愉快.............................................................

許靜怡 said...

支持好的blog~繼續加油~~

洪筱婷 said...

^^~~輕輕鬆鬆的逛部落格,多謝有您的分享哦~~~ .................................................................

婷珊 said...

知識可以傳授,智慧卻不行。每個人必須成為他自己。.................................................................

韋志韋志 said...

Poverty tries friends.................................................................

于庭 said...

成熟,就是有能力適應生活中的模糊。.................................................................

江冠彭珮李佳宏陽筠 said...

Hello~安安唷~很高興見到你哦!!............................................................

姿柯瑩柯dgdd憶曾g智曾 said...

喜歡看大家的文章,祝你順心~^^ ............................................................

偉倫s倪陳合恭陳陳sgdgd陳 said...

很喜歡你的部落格 留言支持你 祝你人氣長紅~~~ ..................................................................

陳璇竹陳璇竹 said...

命運,就是自己行為的結果。..................................................

ju吳phe宇te佳ns said...

我們能互相給予的最佳禮物是「真心的關懷」。..................................................

蔡靜芳蔡靜芳 said...

文章不求沽名釣譽,率性就是真的..................................................................

亦妮亦妮 said...

男女互悅,未必廝守終生,相愛就是美的。.................................................................

佳瑩佳瑩 said...

人生中最好的禮物就是屬於自己的一部份..................................................

陳曉薇陳曉薇 said...

支持你!!!期待你的更新!!!相信一定會更好!!!!............................................................

雅王任 said...

時時關心,時時感動。..................................................

文王廷 said...

一個人的價值,應該看他貢獻了什麼,而不是他取得了什麼.................................................................

凱許倫 said...

教育的目的,不在應該思考什麼,而是教吾人怎樣思考......................................................................

陳倩江陳倩江陳倩江 said...

看看blog調整心情,又要來繼續工作,大家加油............................................................

316 said...

笑口常開~~天天開心............................................................

士文婷文婷松 said...

謝謝大大的分享 我會學會反省與寬容 感恩 ∩△∩............................................................

璇陳陳陳竹 said...

人不能像動物一樣活著,而應該追求知識和美德............................................................

1615 said...

找一個懂妳的人也期許自己做一個人懂別人的人.. ... ............................................................

冰微 said...

文章不求沽名釣譽,率性就是真的..................................................................